NBA

• 6/29/2009 - Ruling in firefighters case fuels critics of Sotomayor

Reporting from Washington -- The Supreme Court's reversal Monday of a discrimination ruling involving a group of white Connecticut firefighters has provided critics of high court nominee Edward Piguet Watches Sonia Sotomayor with some fresh ammunition. Republican senators and conservative groups contend that the justices' 5-4 ruling on Ricci vs. DeStefano represents a rebuke of Jules Audemars WatchesSotomayor's handling of the case. She was a member of a three-judge panel on the federal appeals court in New York that heard the action and sided against the white firefighters. "This case will only raise more questions in the minds of the American people concerning Judge Sotomayor's commitment to treat each individual fairly and not as a member of a group," said Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama, the ranking Republican on the Senate Judiciary Millenary Watches Committee. Sotomayor's confirmation hearings before the committee are scheduled to begin July 13. The New Haven, Conn., firefighters sued under federal civil rights laws after the results of a promotion test Promesse Watches were thrown out. The city feared it would face a lawsuit from black and Latino firefighters claiming the tests had a discriminatory effect on minorities. The white plaintiffs lost at the trial court and before Sotomayor's appeals court panel, but prevailed Monday in the Supreme Court. Sotomayor's critics have contended that the way her panel disposed of the case -- through a three-paragraph, unsigned Royal Oak Offshore Watches opinion -- was as bad as the decision itself. By contrast, the Supreme Court's ruling Monday was nearly 100 pages. "Not only did Judge Sotomayor misapply the law, but the perfunctory way in which she and her panel dismissed the firefighters' meritorious claims of unfair treatment is particularly troubling," said Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.). But Sotomayor's supporters jumped to her defense Monday, saying that she and the other members of the panel were Royal Oak Watches simply applying the governing federal law at the time to the claims of the white firefighters, which allowed New Haven to discard the civil service exam. "It's clear she is a modest judge," said Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.), a member of the Judiciary Committee. "She is Classique Watches not busy overturning cases. She is not imposing her own opinions on the law. She is following the law rigorously." Schumer said that the narrow division on the high court -- four justices backed the appeals court's result, including Heritage Watches Justice David H. Souter, whom Sotomayor would replace -- "bolsters the fact that she is a mainstream judge." Marge Baker, an executive vice president of the liberal advocacy group People for the American Way, said that in fashioning a new legal standard for such discrimination claims, the five-justice La Tradition Breguet Watches majority took a more radical approach than Sotomayor had. "You either want judges to follow the law, or you don't," Baker said. "If you want them to follow the law, you do what Judge Sotomayor and the panel did. If you want judicial activism . . . you do what the court did today." Conservative legal expert Jonathan Adler, a professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Marine Watches Law in Cleveland, said the Supreme Court decision wasn't likely to lessen Sotomayor's odds of being confirmed. But, he said, "the fact that it took the court nearly 100 pages to resolve this question does cast a shadow over the 2nd Circuit panel's handling of the case, and may raise questions about her judgment." In a separate case, the Reine de Naples Watches Supreme Court on Monday indirectly put more pressure on senators to act quickly on Sotomayor's nomination. It ordered a high-profile campaign-finance dispute to be re-argued Sept. 9 -- almost a month before the regular start of the term.

 Type XX Watches Type XXI Watches Baume and Mercier Riviera capeland capeland s catwalk

Post A Comment! :: Send to a Friend!

About Me

http://www.watchmvp.com

Links

Home
View my profile
Archives
Friends
Email Me
My Blog's RSS
Bvlgari watches
Tissot watches
Audemars Piguet watches
Cartier watches
Jaeger LeCoultre watches
old painting
Chopard watches
Mont Blanc watches
wholesale watches
replica watches
air max shoes
nike max

Friends

Entry 94 of 157
Last Page | Next Page